Bird Flu – an increasing risk to animal and human health

by Phil Rasmussen

Aotearoa New Zealand has in the past two weeks detected its first cases of bird flu, a highly contagious strain of the H5N1 influenza A virus, that can spread rapidly in birds(1). This came less than a month after the first case of H5N1 bird flu was detected in Australia.

Waterfowl such as ducks, geese and swans and shorebirds are the natural reservoir of all known influenza A viruses. First detected in poultry in China in 1996, the H5N1 avian influenza virus has evolved into a significant global public health hazard, primarily owing to its high pathogenicity and potential for interspecies transmission. Extensive genetic diversification has occurred since 2005, including the formation of hundreds of genotypes following reassortment with other avian influenza A viruses.  Highly pathogenic H5N1 avian influenza (HPAI) A virus has spread widely through many regions of the world, causing infections of numerous terrestrial, seabird, shorebird, and migratory wild bird species(2). Since 1997, multiple outbreaks of avian influenza in domestic poultry have occurred, and the current 2.3.3.4.4b clade of H5N1 which emerged in 2020, has now become widespread(3, 4).

Migratory birds are the most likely pathway for the virus to come here, as Aotearoa is a seasonal home to several species who migrate from and travel between here and far away places including the Antarctic, other islands in the Pacific, Australia, China, Alaska, Siberia, and northern Asia. The first case was a wild brown skua found on Petone Beach in Lower Hutt.

Efforts to protect some of our already threatened native bird species such as kākāpō, takahē, tūturuatu (shore plover), kakī (black stilt) and kākāriki karaka (orange-fronted parakeet) by vaccination and isolation are underway.  The second bird confirmed to have bird flu here was a native kāhu or swamp harrier hawk, which doesn’t bode well given many of these species are already vulnerable. While vaccination may help save some, it has obvious limitations and only gives around 6 months of protection, therefore additional control measures are urgently needed.

Other biosecurity measures are now being implemented by the Ministry of Primary Industries, Department of Conservation and poultry farmers(5, 6). This includes PSE protection measures, moving chickens indoors, and lockdowns.  As has occurred overseas, it seems likely that New Zealand poultry farms will at some stage become affected by this virus, potentially leading to the deaths of many millions of birds.

Potential transmission to dairy cows

Highly pathogenic H5N1 influenza was first detected in dairy cows in Texas in March 2024. The virus then disseminated rapidly, causing widespread outbreaks in dairy cattle across the United States(7, 8, 9, 10). Over 1000 herds in at least 19 states have been affected to date(11, 12).

Most cattle recovered in two to three weeks with supportive care, but the impact of the virus on dairy cattle varied from nonclinical to severe clinical signs and death. Up to 20% of each herd in the U.S. outbreaks developed clinical disease with symptoms such as reduced milk production, thicker colostrum-like milk, reduced appetite, lethargy, fever and dehydration. This lead to substantial economic losses(9, 12).  

At first, many American dairy producers did not report clinical signs in their cows or test for the virus. Cats and peridomestic birds on many affected farms died from viral exposure. A number of dairy workers showed signs of conjunctivitis, which was confirmed to be due to H5N1(12).

This represents a significant expansion in the mammalian host range of highly pathogenic H5N1.  Genomic analysis and epidemiological investigation suggests a reassortment event in wild bird populations preceded a single wild bird-to-cattle transmission episode. The movement of asymptomatic or presymptomatic cattle also likely played a role in the spread of HPAI within the United States dairy sector(7).

While infectious virus is detected in milk following mammary infection, unpasteurised milk ingestion by calves doesn’t seem to cause overt disease(13). However, the risk to humans from drinking raw (unpasteurised) milk from infected cows remains unknown, and virologists in the US have advised against this.  American authorities have confirmed that pasteurization inactivated the virus in dairy products and showed that it was very rarely detected in beef from affected cows.

Two years later, the U.S. outbreak of the H5N1 influenza virus in cattle appears to be waning, easing fears that it could cause long-lasting damage to the dairy industry or mutate into a human pandemic form. However, it remains a problem in some states, and efforts to eliminate it entirely face formidable challenges.  The mechanisms of transmission within and between dairy herds also remains a critical question that has yet to be fully answered(13, 14). American virologists have advocated strongly for precautions to be taken by dairy or poultry farm workers, and that those with backyard birds, chickens or pigeons, should also be careful. Keeping dogs and cats away from dead birds,  is also recommended(15).

The persistence of the H5N1 virus in U.S. dairy cattle and the fact it has adapted to infect another key mammalian species, coupled with its broad and unprecedented host range, are alarming developments. It also presents a public health threat due to the establishment of distinct transmission chains linking wild birds, cattle, the environment, and humans.

This is highly relevant to our situation here in Aotearoa New Zealand, given that the dairy industry is our largest export earner, and is based largely on outdoor grazing. While the U.S. outbreak has to date been confined to that country, the risk of transmission of bird flu from wild or migratory birds to cattle as occurred in the U.S., appears very real. If highly pathogenic H5N1 become established in dairy cows here, it could have serious biosecurity, public health and economic consequences. Measures to increase surveillance, develop animal vaccines and treatment agents, enhance farm biosecurity, and continue to ensure dairy product safety, should be considered. Incorporation of a medicinal plant programme, could also make a valuable contribution as part of these measures.

Risk to Humans

While primarily affecting avian species, H5N1 has repeatedly breached species barriers, infecting mammals including seals, dolphins, seals, foxes, otters and cattle(16). As with the SARS-1 and SARS-2 (Covid-19) viruses, which originated from viruses in birds and bats, H5N1 also has the potential to infect humans.

The first known human infection with a highly pathogenic H5N1 influenza A virus appeared in China in 1997. Between 2003 and 2017, the WHO documented an additional 862 human cases, mainly from southeast Asia and Egypt, with a mean annual case fatality rate of 56%(17).

Human cases fell after 2016, but H5N1 clade 2.3.4.4b viruses then appeared in Europe and spread rapidly to the Americas. Human infections of this genotype have been relatively rare to date, and until the US dairy outbreak, mostly occurred in those with unprotected exposure to sick birds. Many instances of poultry workers being infected have been reported(18).

Since the start of the USA dairy outbreak, the H5N1 virus spread from dairy cattle to cats, mice, peridomestic birds, species such as skunks and raccoons, as well as humans.  Between March 2024 and May 2025,  70 human cases of highly pathogenic H5N1 were reported in the United States, although it is likely that the true number of cases was considerably more(12). Of these 41 were exposed to dairy cows, 24 to commercial poultry, two to backyard poultry and three had an unidentified source of exposure. All sequenced viruses were clade 2.3.4.4b. Overall, 62 cases (89%) reported eye redness, 32 (46%) fever and 29 (41%) respiratory symptoms; 54 of 67 cases (81%) reported receiving antiviral treatment. Most illnesses were mild; however, four patients were hospitalized. Of the hospitalized patients, three had pneumonia and one died(19).

While evolution of the virus to a strain capable of rapid human-to-human transmission hasn’t occurred as yet, history and science tell us that such a worrying development remains possible.

The 1918-1920 so-called Spanish flu (which actually began in the U.S.), was caused by a highly lethal strain of the H1N1 subtype of the influenza A virus, which likely originated in birds, before adapting in humans. This was an RNA virus that spread incredibly fast worldwide, ultimately infecting an estimated one-third of the global population and causing the deaths of an estimated 20 to 30 million people(20, 21). Despite our understanding of viral transmission and public health measures now being better than they were in 1918, the potential for an epidemic or pandemic is a concern.

Several outbreaks of bird flu have occurred since 2005, when H5N1 in birds was described as “public health enemy number 1”, and likely to lead to a global pandemic. At that time, highly pathogenic H5N1 influenza A viruses were spreading relentlessly across the globe, causing widespread death in poultry, substantial economic loss to farmers, and infections reported in more than 300 people with a very high mortality rate of 60%(22). As it happened, Covid-19 pipped it at the post, but that didn’t mean that the risk of a future H5N1 pandemic went away.

Detection of the D1.1 genotype primarily circulating in wild birds, was reported in dairy cows in early 2025. Unlike the B3.13 virus circulating in cattle, this has been associated with severe disease in humans, and resulted in two deaths(17, 23). The co-circulation of B3.13 and D1.1 viruses in dairy cows increases the risk of reassortment and viral evolution to a more virulent strain. Genotype D1.1 has now also been detected in domestic cats.

However humans have some residual or existing immunity to H5N1 through our long term exposure to other influenza viruses such as H1N1(24).  Studies in ferrets and using human organoids suggest that currently available seasonal influenza vaccines may confer some degree of protection against H5N1. To what extent however, is as yet unknown(24, 25).

It is hard to know how close we are to the H5N1 virus evolving to become much more virulent in humans. However, reassortment in particular, when co-infection with two viruses occurs (such as a dairy farm worker already with influenza, picking up H5N1), presents a possible mechanism of increased virulence developing.

Some useful phytomedicines

Medicinal plants, having being the mainstay of how humans and animals have treated themselves when unwell throughout virtually all of history, deserve much more attention for their potential value in dealing with H5N1.

In 2005, with a previous version of H5N1 circulating in many bird species around the globe and fears mounting of this triggering a human pandemic, I researched the history of infectious viral diseases and what was known about the H5N1 strains at the time(26, 27).

Below is a reproduction of part of an article I wrote on Avian Influenza in November 2005, for a practitioner publication produced by a company I founded and was then managing. While an update is now called for, much of the information provided is still highly relevant to the current H5N1 situation here in Aotearoa New Zealand.

Avian Influenza Update; excerpts from an article by Phil Rasmussen & edited by Noeline Jonkers, in Phytonews 23, published by Phytomed Medicinal Herbs Ltd, November 2005:

Echinacea:

Echinacea has been shown in animal studies to impart protection against mortality from various viruses(28,29), and several clinical trials have shown beneficial effects of Echinacea during the treatment of colds and influenza(30-34).

Increased numbers of circulating white blood cells, monocytes, neutrophils and natural killer (NK) cells, and the phagocytotic abilities of these, are the principle immunological changes associated with Echinacea root usage. These effects are all a reflection of enhancement of the non-specific immune response, whereby the body’s ability to maintain immunosurveillance against a variety of potential viral or bacterial pathogens or spontaneous-developing tumours, is increased.  This aspect of the immune response is quite different to that of the specific immune system as provoked by vaccination, whereby production of specific disease-related antibodies and a subsequent immune response occurs.

Certain of the above effects of Echinacea may at first seem counterproductive during the acute stage of an established H5N1 infection, in which much of the immune system could well be over-activated as described earlier. While activation of innate immune mechanisms such as NK cell activity is useful in the early immune response to most types of influenza(35,36), excessive enhancement of NK cell activity during the acute stage of a H5N1 infection, could perhaps be associated with a theoretical worsening of lung function(37).

At this point however, it is perhaps important to recognise that Echinacea root exhibits pharmacological actions better summarised as being immunomodulatory and anti-inflammatory rather than simply immunostimulant. Its use by experienced practitioners for autoimmune conditions such as asthma and eczema, is also due to its perceived actions as a modulator or regulator of a poorly functioning overall immune system. Additionally, while activation of several inflammatory as well as anti-inflammatory cytokines has been shown for Echinacea both in vitro and in vivo, the specific actions and potencies in this regard vary depending on the type of Echinacea product concerned.

Anti-inflammatory effects of Echinacea root are well established from both its traditional use to treat snake bites and major abscesses, as well as modern pharmacological studies(38-41). Recent studies have also shown that Echinacea alkamides produce a dual modulatory rather than simple stimulant effect on TNF-a expression in humans(42). These and other effects of Echinacea on gene expressions indicate a broad spectrum anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory response(43), including reduced expression of IL-1β, IL-8 and TNF-α.  Such effects could be helpful during the acute stages of H5N1 infection.

While speculative, modulation of TNF-a and other cytokine expression by Echinacea could therefore be useful in a situation of H5N1 infection during which TNF-α and cytokine production in general, is dysregulated. In addition to these anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects, antioxidant actions by Echinacea could also be helpful during this situation(44).

However, while adequate doses of a good quality Echinacea preparation have been shown to enhance the capability of the body’s immune system to combat existing upper respiratory tract infections, whether such effects would occur to help hasten elimination of a virulent H5N1 infection, remain unknown.

The question also arises as to whether Echinacea is best used as a possible preventative agent to optimise immune defences ready for when an avian influenza pandemic occurs, rather than a treatment when an individual infection has occurred. Optimising immunosurveillance and activity of the non-specific immune system against such a virulent pathogen, while less likely to ensure complete protection than appropriate vaccination, may prevent such a virulent and life-threatening response to its presence.

Other phytomedicines:

Shikimic acid is a phenolic acid compound used as a key starting material in the manufacture of oseltamivir, and found in many plants including Chinese Star Anise (Illicium verum)(45). While this and other shikimic acid rich plants have been increasingly sought after since fears of a pandemic escalated, little evidence exists that shikimic acid itself or plants containing it, could be useful.

American ginseng (Panax quinqefolium) root has a protective effect against winter influenza in institutionalised older adults (see Phytonews 20(46)). More recently, a preventative effect against winter colds has been reported following daily use for 4 months, in a Canadian study involving 323 subjects aged 18-65 years of age(47). A higher immune response from influenza vaccination, has also been produced by concurrent administration of the closely related Panax ginseng(48).

The popular Chinese herb Astragalus membranaceous, traditionally used to help manage viral infections such as the common cold, has also shown some evidence of immune stimulation and antiviral effects(49-51).

Elderflower (Sambucus nigra) is generally used for its diaphoretic and decongestant properties, particularly during hay fever as well as catarrh and fever associated with the common cold or influenza. A clinical trial has found elderberry to have in vitro antiviral effects and reduce the duration and severity of influenza symptoms(52), and possible immunostimulant properties have been reported(53).

The root of Ginger (Zingiber officinale) has immunomodulatory(53) and antiviral properties(55-57), which along with its anti-inflammatory actions, may be useful. The fungus Reishi (Ganoderma lucidum), has established immunomodulatory effects and enhances innate immunity by activating NF-kappaB(58).

Olive leaf (Olea europaea) has become popular over recent years as an alleged treatment for winter influenza, although little published research has appeared until recently(59).

Propolis, the resinous material manufactured by bees from plants and rich in flavonoids, shows in vitro activity against various viruses(60,61), and has proven immunomodulatory and anti-inflammatory effects including down-regulation of inflammatory cytokine production(62,63).

Various plants contain compounds which act as neuraminidase inhibitors in vitro in the same manner as oseltamivir. The best studied of these is 5,7,4”-trihydroxy-8-methoxyflavone(64,65), a flavone closely related to baicalin and baicalein and found in roots of the popular Chinese herb Baical Skullcap (Scutellaria baicalensis), as well as aerial parts of the well-known European Skullcap (Scutellaria lateriflora).

A study just reported using a Chinese formula containing a large amount of baicalin in a pre-clinical animal model of endotoxin-induced lung injury, found a marked reduction in elevated plasma levels and the expressions of several inflammatory cytokines, in lung tissues. The formulation itself (San-Huang-Xie-Xin-Tang), as well as baicalin alone, also reduced plasma concentrations of IL-1b, TNF-α, and expressions of other cytokines associated with lung injury and lethality(66).

This study as well as another finding in vitro antiviral activity against SARS coronavirus for baicalin(66), provides strong support for a potential role for baicalin-containing phytomedicines  in the treatment of acute H5N1 infection. The well-established anti-inflammatory, antioxidant and antimicrobial activities of Baical Skullcap(68), would seem to make further research on this phytomedicine in particular, highly justified.

Other neuraminidase inhibitors include resveratrol (found in red grapes) and emodin derivatives, anthraquinone compounds found in Aloe vera and a number of other laxative phytomedicines(69). The strong laxative effects of these would probably be major limitations to their clinical usefulness at this stage. As for all such compounds, considerations of bioavailability and dosage of each of these herbal medicines that would be required for significant activities need to be made.

With excessive inflammation in the lungs being increasingly related to the virulence of  H5N1, treatment of infected patients with anti-inflammatory drugs or herbal medicines may in some cases be useful. However while the use of corticosteroids together with antiviral medication has been reported to confer clinical benefits in some cases of SARS(70), clinical trials are lacking and such steroid therapy has been linked with residual lung damage following treatment. There nevertheless remains a theoretical potential role for anti-inflammatory phytomedicines or phytochemicals such as curcumin, a key constituent of the cheap spice Turmeric, which is a significant inhibitor of TNF and could help reduce the adverse effects of excessive cytokine release.

While in all cases it is at this stage conjectural as to whether these or other various natural treatments would be helpful during an H5N1 pandemic, the seriousness of the situation now arising warrants a systematic evaluation of these and other herbal medicines as possible alternative or adjunctive treatments to anti-viral drug or vaccine therapy. 

July 2026 Update:

Significantly, each of the aforementioned herbs as well as the propolis made by bees using plant phytochemicals, are already being grown or can easily be grown here in Aotearoa and their production scaled up rapidly, provided the required commitment and funding support to do so, is provided.

One of these, Scutellaria baicalensis (Baical Skullcap) is a widely used medicinal plant in Asia, and one of the species that I am participating in growing trials with, involving a landowner group here in Aotearoa New Zealand. I recommended this species for the trials based upon the huge amount of scientific evidence for its effectiveness in many human health conditions, my clinical experience with using it in hundreds of patients, its growing global demand, our need to strengthen our medicine security and diversify our rural economies, and a view it would grow very well in our country.  Early results from these trials have been promising.

As I summarised in blogs in April and October last year, Baical skullcap has recently been shown to possess potential applications for animal health in addition to its well-established benefits to treat human illnesses including infectious and neurological diseases, inflammatory and allergic conditions and cancer(71, 72). A study published last year by Chinese researchers also found an extract of the stems and leaves of Baical skullcap to offer promise in helping farmers to manage respiratory tract pathogens in laying hens.(73)

Supplementation of chickens vaccinated against the H5N1 avian influenza virus with oral extracts from Astragalus and Ginseng (two other species which are being trialed or cultivated here in Aotearoa), has been shown to increase their antibody production and immune response. This suggests their potential also as adjunctive treatments, to protect chickens against this virus(74).  Researchers in Thailand recently screened some Asian medicinal plant extracts and found ethanolic extracts of turmeric root as well as the leaf of guava (Psidium guajava), to have good in vitro activity against the H5N1 influenza virus(75).

A call to Action

Highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) H5N1 continues to pose a serious threat to global health due to its increasing geographic spread, expanding host range including recent mammalian infections, and relatively high mortality in human cases.

The potentially devastating impact of this highly pathogenic H5N1 virus on our native birds as well as poultry industry, and risk of spread to the dairy industry, calls for urgent steps from the government and industry sectors and stakeholders.  The propensity of this strain of H5N1 to mutate, and potentially into a form more easily transmissible between humans, is a reason for concern. To effectively manage highly pathogenic avian influenza, a comprehensive, collaborative and forward thinking programme that invokes the principals of a One Health perspective involving all stakeholders, is recommended.

Despite the availability of vaccines and antivirals for seasonal influenza, effective prophylactic and treatment options for H5N1 remain limited.  Several drugs show promise in preclinical studies, but clinical data specifically for H5N1 is lacking.

Fortunately, compelling research suggests that several medicinal plants could make a valuable contribution as part of these management efforts, many of which we can easily grow here. Incorporating some of these into longer term farm management practices would also have other sustained benefits for our important animal based agricultural economy, as well as our resilience as a food producing nation, and protection of our rich native species biodiversity.

References:

  1. First case of bird flu confirmed in New Zealand. New Zealand Herald, 15 July 2026.
  2. Shi J, Zeng X, Cui P, Yan C, Chen H. Alarming situation of emerging H5 and H7 avian influenza and effective control strategies. Emerg Microbes Infect. 2023 Dec;12(1):2155072. 
  3. Krammer F, Hermann E, Rasmussen AL. Highly pathogenic avian influenza H5N1: history, current situation, and outlook. J Virol. 2025 Apr 15;99(4):e0220924. 
  4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Technical report: June 2024 highly pathogenic avian influenza A (H5N1) viruses. https://www.cdc.gov/bird-flu/php/technical-report/h5n1-06052024.html.
  5. https://www.mpi.govt.nz/biosecurity-in-nz/dont-let-bird-flu-take-flight?utm_source=google&utm_medium=paidsearch&utm_campaign=High+Pathogenicity+Avian+Influenza+H5N1+2025-26&gad_source=1
  6. https://birdflu.pianz.org.nz/
  7. Nguyen TQ, Hutter CR, Markin A, Thomas M et al, Emergence and interstate spread of highly pathogenic avian influenza A(H5N1) in dairy cattle in the United States. Science. 2025 Apr 25;388(6745):eadq0900.
  8. Caserta LC, Frye EA, Butt SL, Laverack M et al. Spillover of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5N1 virus to dairy cattle. Nature. 2024 Oct;634(8034):669-676. doi: 10.1038/s41586-024-07849-4. 
  9. Peña-Mosca F, Frye EA, MacLachlan MJ, Rebelo AR et al, The impact of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5N1 virus infection on dairy cows. Nat Commun. 2025 Jul 15;16(1):6520.
  10. Lewis N, Beer M. Stop H5N1 influenza in US cattle now. Science. 2024 Jul 12;385(6705):123. doi: 10.1126/science.adr5866. Epub 2024 Jul 11. PMID: 38991057.
  11. https://www.cdc.gov/bird-flu/situation-summary/mammals.html
  12. Lombard J, Stenkamp-Strahm C, McCluskey B, Abdul-Hamid C, Cardona C, Petersen B, Russo K. Invited review: The One Health challenges and opportunities of the H5N1 outbreak in dairy cattle in the United States. J Dairy Sci. 2025 Jul;108(7):6513-6537. 
  13. Lee C, Tarbuck NN, Cochran HJ, Foreman BM et al, Dairy cows infected with influenza A(H5N1) reveals low infectious dose and transmission barriers. Nat Commun. 2026 May 24. doi: 10.1038/s41467-026-73490-6.
  14. Ding K, Ding Y. H5N1 avian influenza in dairy cattle: Molecular adaptation, transmission mechanisms, and control strategies. Virology. 2026 Aug;621:110927. 
  15. https://www.avma.org/resources-tools/animal-health-and-welfare/animal-health/avian-influenza/avian-influenza-virus-type-h5n1-us-dairy-cattle
  16. Man W, Du L, Liu Y, Pang Z et al, Evolution of H5N1 Cross-Species Transmission: Adaptive Mutations Driving Avian-to-Human Infection. Adv Genet (Hoboken). 2026 Jan 11;7(1):e00051.
  17. Sykes JE. Companion animals and H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza: cause for concern? J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2025 Aug 8;263(11):1355-1363. 
  18. Hatta Y, De La Cruz JA, Murray T, Hiatt B et al, Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza A(H5N1) Clade 2.3.4.4b Virus Infection in Poultry Farm Workers, Washington, USA, 2024. Emerg Infect Dis. 2025 Dec;31(12):2297-2301.
  19. Rolfes MA, Kniss K, Kirby MK, Garg S et al, Human infections with highly pathogenic avian influenza A(H5N1) viruses in the United States from March 2024 to May 2025. Nat Med. 2025 Nov;31(11):3889-3898
  20. Taubenberger JK, Kash JC, Morens DM. The 1918 influenza pandemic: 100 years of questions answered and unanswered. Sci Transl Med. 2019 Jul 24;11(502):eaau5485.
  21. Köntös Z. Lessons should be learned: Why did we not learn from the Spanish flu? SAGE Open Med. 2024 May 29;12:20503121241256820.
  22. Gambotto A, Barratt-Boyes SM, de Jong MD, Neumann G, Kawaoka Y. Human infection with highly pathogenic H5N1 influenza virus. Lancet. 2008 Apr 26;371(9622):1464-75
  23. Mezhenskaia D, Babujee L, Lim A, Guan L, Nguyen D, Gu C, Neumann G, Poulsen K, Eisfeld AJ, Kawaoka Y. Isolation and characterization of a clade 2.3.4.4b genotype D1.1 H5N1 virus from dairy cattle in Wisconsin. J Virol. 2026 Jul 10:e0076126.
  24. Li C, Yu Y, Wan Z, Cai JP et al. Cattle and human organoids reveal 2.3.4.4b H5N1 cross-species transmission potential and neuraminidase-specific neutralizing antibodies in humans. Nat Commun. 2026 Jul 8;17(1):5585. 
  25. Tseng I, Huang YC, Shih WL, Chou CH et al, Cross-protection against highly pathogenic avian influenza H5N1 virus from seasonal influenza vaccines: a systematic review and meta-analysis of ferret studies. Emerg Microbes Infect. 2026 Dec;15(1):2654278.
  26. Rasmussen PL, Person to person transmission of Avian Influenza. Phytonews 21, published by Phytomed Medicinal Herbs Ltd, Auckland, New Zealand, March 2005. ISSN 1175-0251.
  27. Rasmussen PL, Avian Influenza Update. Phytonews 23, published by Phytomed Medicinal Herbs Ltd, Auckland, New Zealand, November 2005. ISSN 1175-0251
  28. Hayashi I et al, Nihon Rinsho Meneki Gakkai Kaishi.;24(1):10-20. Feb 2001.
  29. Currier NL, Miller SC. J Altern Complement Med 7(3):241-251, Jun 2001.
  30. Giles et al. Pharmacotherapy. 20(6):690-7, 2000.
  31. Melchart et al. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. (2):CD000530, 2000.
  32. Percival SS. Biochem Pharmacol. 60(2):155-8, 2000.
  33. Hoheisel O. et al,  Eur. J. Clinical Research, 9, 261-268, 1997.
  34. Barnes J et al, J Pharm Pharmacol 57(8):929-954, Aug 2005.
  35. He XS et al. J Clin Invest.;114(12):1812-9. Dec 2004.
  36. Liu B et al, J Gen Virol 85(Pt 2):423-8, Feb 2004.
  37. Wei H  et al, J Allergy Clin Immunol. 115(4):841-7. Apr 2005.
  38. Tragni E. et al, Pharmacol Res Comm, 20(5), 87-90, 1988.
  39. Muller-Jakic, B. et al, Planta Med 60(1), 37-40, 1994.
  40. Clifford et al. Phytomedicine. 9(3):249-53,  2002.
  41. Rasmussen P Phytonews 14 12, Phytomed Medicinal Herbs Ltd, Auckland, New Zealand. ISSN 1175-0251, December 2002.
  42. Gertsch J et al, FEBS Lett 577, 563-569, 2004.
  43. Randolph RK et al, Exp Biol Med (Maywood).;228(9):1051-6. Oct 2003.
  44. Goel V et al, Phytother Res 19. 689-694, 2005.
  45. Lee SW et al, Planta Med 69(9):861-864, Sept 2003.
  46. Rasmussen P Phytonews 20 4, Phytomed Medicinal Herbs Ltd, Auckland, New Zealand. ISSN 1175-0251, December 2004.
  47. Predy GN 2005 CMAJ. 25;173(9):1043-8. Oct 2005.
  48. Scaglione F et al, Drugs Exp Clin Res 22(2):65-72, 1996.
  49. Block KI, Mead MN. Integr Cancer Ther 2(3):247-267, Sept 2003.
  50. Yesilada E et al, J Ethnopharmacol. 4;96(1-2):71-7. Jan 2005
  51. Guo FC et al. Poult Sci. 83(7):1124-32. Jul 2004
  52. Zakay-Rones Z et al, J Altern Complement Med 1(4):361-369, 1995.
  53. Barak V et al, Isr Med Assoc J 4(11 Suppl):919-922, Nov 2002.
  54. Sohni Y et al, J Ethnopharmacol 54(2-3):119, 1996.
  55. Denyer CV et al, J Nat Prod 57(5):658-662, May 1994.
  56. Dugenci SK et al, J Ethnopharmacol  88(1):99-106. Sep 2003
  57. Chrubasik S et al, Phytomedicine 12(9):684-701. Review. Sep 2005
  58. Kuo MC J Ethnopharmacol. 14; Sep 2005
  59. Micol V et al. Antiviral Res.66(2-3):129-36. Jun. 2005
  60. Adb El Hady FK, Hegazi AG. Z Naturforsch 57(3-4):386-394, Mar-Apr 2002.
  61. GekkerG et al. Ethnopharmacol 87(1):93-97, Jul 2003.
  62. Ansorge S et al, Z Naturforsch 58(7-8):580-589, Jul-Aug 2003.
  63. Sa-Nunes A et al, J Ethnopharmacol 87(1):93-97, Jul 2003.
  64. Nagai T et al, Chem Pharm Bull 38(5):1329-1332, May 1990.
  65. Nagai T et al, Antiviral Res 26(1):11-25, Jan 1995.
  66. Lo YC et al, J Ethnopharmacol 101(1-3):68-74, Oct 3, 2005.
  67. Chen F et al, J Clin Virol 31(1):69-75, Sept 2004.
  68. Chuang HN et al, Planta Med 71(5):440-445, May 2005.
  69. Lee CH et al, Arch Pharm Res 26(5):367-374, May 2003.
  70. Wang C-H et al, Resp Res 6:42, 2005.
  71. Rasmussen PL, Baical Skullcap – useful for anxiety, neurological & mood disorders. www.herbblurb.com Oct 17, 2005.
  72. Rasmussen PL, Baical Skullcap – additional uses for aerial parts. www.herbblurb.com Apr 7,  2005.
  73. Wang X, Wu S, Guo N, Yu F et al, Scutellaria baicalensis stem and leaf combat chicken-derived respiratory bacterial infection. Microb Pathog. 2025 May;202:107439. 
  74. Abdullahi AY, Kallon S, Yu X, Zhang Y, Li G. Vaccination with Astragalus and Ginseng Polysaccharides Improves Immune Response of Chickens against H5N1 Avian Influenza Virus. Biomed Res Int. 2016;2016:1510264.
  75. Sornpet B, Potha T, Tragoolpua Y, Pringproa K. Antiviral activity of five Asian medicinal pant crude extracts against highly pathogenic H5N1 avian influenza virus. Asian Pac J Trop Med. 2017 Sep;10(9):871-876.

ADHD and useful Phytomedicines

Introduction

ADHD (Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder) is a chronic neuro-behavioural condition characterised by a persistent pattern of inattention, hyperactivity and impulsiveness. It can disrupt education and social development of children and teenagers, and have a huge impact on a person’s life, yet is often undiagnosed.

The DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) describes three subtypes of ADHD. These include: ADHD-Inattentive type (ADHD-I), ADHD-Hyperactive/impulsive (ADHD-H), and ADHD-Combined type (ADHD-C). The presentation can change over time though, and a diagnosis provided at one specific time may differ from that provided at another time in a person’s life.

While reported rates of ADHD are higher than in the past, this is likely to be at least partially due to better recognition of the condition. It is a common condition among young children, and an estimated 50% of these retain ADHD symptoms for the rest of their lives. Research suggests around 5-8 percent of the population has ADHD but only 1-2 percent are diagnosed.  Diagnosis rates have historically been higher in boys than in girls, although rates are now thought to be similar for both genders.

Diagnosis of ADHD can be difficult and there is no diagnostic biological marker. Symptoms should have been present and persistent for a minimum of six months prior to the age of 12, are maladaptive, and cannot be explained by other psychiatric or medical disorders. However, often symptoms may not meet the criteria for a formal diagnosis of ADHD, despite causing significant issues in learning, social and family relationships.  

Symptoms

Impairing levels of inattention, disorganisazion, and/or hyperactivity-impulsivity, are key features of ADHD.  These symptoms are excessive for the age or development level.

In a classroom setting, children with ADHD will often tune out or appear to daydream. They can talk a lot, interrupt others and are unable to wait for their turn. Such children are frequently called out in class or a group or become known as the ‘class clown’, or the subject of bullying. These behaviours can exacerbate difficulties in ‘fitting in’ with peer groups or societal expectations.

While not an anxiety disorder as such, a large proportion of children with ADHD have coexisting psychiatric disorders, including but not limited to depression, bipolar disorder, autism spectrum disorders, eating disorders, and anxiety disorders (1). Adults with ADHD also often have an anxiety or substance use disorder, which can mask ADHD symptoms, sometimes for many years(2). Those with ADHD are also more likely to do dangerous and impulsive things.

Aetiology

Several potentially aetiological factors have been identified. ADHD has a significant familial and genetic predisposition, although the extent of the latter is somewhat contentious. Approximately 30% of children with epilepsy have ADHD .

Environmental contributions such as early childhood exposure to toxic heavy metals (especially lead) or phthalates, have received increased attention in recent years(3-7). Air pollution has also been associated with neurodevelopmental disorders including ADHD(8).

Other studies have associated ADHD with a higher prevalence of smoking, alcohol consumption, and excessive screen time among adolescents(9-11). Dysfunctions have been reported with BDNF (Brain derived neurotrophic factor) metabolism, dopaminergic neurotransmission, and with neurochemical parthways within the prefrontal cortex(12, 13).

However, these associations are complex, and to what extent they are aetiological versus outcome manifestations in those with ADHD, remains debatable.

Increasing greenness exposure or ‘nature medicine’, is likely to help protect against ADHD and other mental health conditions. A large New Zealand study has reported that children who always lived in a rural area after 2 years of age, were significantly less likely to develop ADHD(14 ).  Similar findings were reported in a German study, with residential greenness being protective, but air pollution being a risk factor(15).

Dietary factors may be contributory in some cases. Inattention was negatively correlated with fruit and vegetable consumption and a healthy dietary pattern, in a large population-based Swedish study (16). Some evidence suggests Vitamin D deficiency may be relevant to the pathogenesis of ADHD and autism, and supplementation with this as well as zinc and magnesium, both important cofactors in dopamine metabolism, may be useful(17, 18).

Treatments

The use of stimulant medications and particularly methylphenidate, is the usual treatment for ADHD. Methylphenidate is structurally similar to amphetamines, inhibits the reuptake of dopamine and noradrenaline, and leads to symptom improvement in around seventy percent of patients.  

Dexamphetamine is also occasionally used, as is its prodrug lisdexamfetamine. The selective noradrenaline reuptake inhibitors atomoxetine and viloxazine, are sometimes prescribed. These and alpha-2 adrenergic agonists guanfacine and clonidine, which stimulate noradrenergic neurotransmission in the prefrontal cortex, are occasionally used when stimulants or these drugs are not suitable or tolerated.

Reduced appetite, sleeping difficulties, nausea and abdominal pain are the most common adverse events to stimulant medication. Rare but serious adverse events can include cardiac problems, weight loss, mood fluctuations and psychotic disorders. These can cause concern as treatment can continue from childhood into adolescence and beyond.

Official guidelines discourage the use of medication in children under the age of six, although these are sometimes prescribed by a specialist in severe cases. ‘Off-label’ use of medicines in this age group, is increasingly common. However, few studies have taken place involving the use of ADHD drugs in very young children, and safety and efficacy data is generally lacking. 

Treatment programmes should also include psychological interventions such as counselling or psychotherapy, with patients’ and parents’ preferences and need for such treatment, always considered(19).  It is also often beneficial to not only treat a child, teenager or adult with ADHD, but also offer phytotherapy or other treatment support to their parents, partners or other family members. Adjunctive phytomedicines and sometimes lifestyle and dietary changes, can be very helpful.

Of note is that there are several disparities  in treatment guidelines and the selection and sequencing of various medications  in different countries. Danish guidelines for instance, do not recommend methylphenidate, lisdexamfetamine or atomoxetine as first line treatment options, while German guidelines provide specific drug recommendations tailored to individual comorbidities (1). A greater emphasis on psychotherapy, school and parental support systems and a higher bar before methylphenidate medication is trialed, is applied in some jurisdictions, particularly those where health care expenditure per capita is higher.

Some Useful Phytomedicines

An individualised treatment protocol incorporating plant medicines can offer much to ADHD patients. They can also help children who are resistant to stimulant medications, or those who wish to not take these medicines, or to keep drug dosage needs as low as possible.

Treatment selection depends on the particular type of ADHD, its symptomatology, and of course individual patient needs and wishes.  Given the diverse presentation of ADHD, a range of phytomedicines should be considered. An individualised but ‘trial and error’ approach is recommended, but desirable actions can include neuroprotection, cognition enhancement, anxiolytic and stimulant properties. Any use of other medications or presence of other health conditions should be taken into account.  Addressing other co –existing mental or physical health issues, can in itself often produce significant benefits, and sometimes avoid the need for additional drug-based interventions.

Where restlessness or accompanying anxiety are part of the symptomatology, anxiolytic and relaxant phytomedicines can be useful.  They include Bacopa, Chamomile, Holy basil, Kava, Lavender, Lemon balm, Skullcap, Passionflower, Skullcap, Valerian, Withania and more(20).  Many of these (Ginkgo, Bacopa, Lemon Balm, Valerian, Withania) also have neuroprotective activities and when used appropriately, can help improve cognition and learning outcomes.

Leaves of the Indian plant Bacopa (Bacopa monniera) have been used for anxiolytic and memory enhancing purposes for centuries. As with Ginkgo and Lemon Balm, it is neuroprotective and may help with cognition and attention deficit disorders. It is frequently used in the management of ADHD and autism in children and teenagers.

A recent 14 week Australian clinical trial into Bacopa’s effects in boys with ADHD aged 6-14, found no significant behavioural improvement. However, improvements occurred in their sleep routine and in cognitive flexibility and interpersonal problems(21).  Reduced symptoms of restlessness and improvement in self control, were reported in a smaller open label study in children with ADHD(22).  It is safe in children, although as a liquid its bitter taste can be an issue, particularly as dosage needs tend to be quite high.

Ginkgo (Ginkgo biloba) can be helpful in ADHD or for cognitive deficits in children, and combines very well with other psychoactive phytomedicines such as St Johns wort and anxiolytics. It is also hepatoprotective, and can be helpful when concomitant drug medications which can cause liver or kidney damage, are being taken.

Lemon balm (Melissa officinalis) is another generally safe anxiolytic, and like chamomile is indicated particularly where gastrointestinal upsets or eating disorders are associated with feelings of anxiety(23).  It can also help with cognition in teenagers, though large doses are generally required.

The Chinese medicinal herb Rehmannia (Rehmannia glutinosa) was reported to reduce impulsive and spontaneous behaviour and ameliorate hippocampal neurodevelopmental abnormalities an a rat model of ADHD(24).

Passionflower (Passiflora incarnata), has been shown to help control anxiety in several studies involving adult patients(25) . A combination with St Johns wort and Valerian was reported to reduce nervous agitation in children aged between 6 and 12 years(26)  .  Potential benefits in ADHD and autism, have been reported(27, 28), although larger and better controlled clinical trials are needed.

Kava (Piper methysticum) also has a place in the management of ADHD in some children and adults. Its effectiveness in treating anxiety has been affirmed through several clinical trials and meta-analyses. It may also exhibit a mild antipsychotic effect and be helpful for children with OCD or autism.

Withania (Withania somnifera) is a useful allrounder when it comes to anxiety and stress-associated conditions. As with all adaptogens, it acts on multiple relevant sites of action, neurotransmitter and hormonal systems(29), and is often an effective component of the treatment of ADHD in both young and older people.

St Johns wort (Hypericum perforatum) is our best known clinically effective antidepressant, and I have used it successfully in many hundreds of patients, over the past thirty years. While beyond the scope of this article, concerns about its safety and interactions with other medications, are also often unjustified, this depending on the type of St Johns wort used, and its phytochemical profile(30).

ADHD is now recognised as a common neurodivergent condition, which if not well managed and treated can cause enormous emotional and mental suffering in children, teenagers, adults and their friends and families.

Summary

As with most chronic health conditions, early diagnosis and interventions which are natural and affordable and incorporate a selfcare approach, can produce huge benefits and avoid the need for more serious treatments later on.  While not denying the usefulness of drug medications such as methylphenidate and atomoxetine, it is concerning given the frequency at which these can cause adverse events, that they are being so widely prescribed and relied upon.

If the need for a long term drug prescription can be avoided or drug dosage requirements kept to a minimum through the concomitant use of more natural interventions, then this is a preferred approach. While there is a need for further and larger clinical trials involving phytomedicines in the treatment of ADHD, many medicinal plants exhibit pharmacological actions of benefit to those dealing with this condition, and treatment targeted for each person’s individual clinical presentation, can produce huge benefits.

References:

  1. Van Vyve L, Dierckx B, Lim CG, Danckaerts M, Koch BCP, Häge A, Banaschewski T. Pharmacotherapy for ADHD in children and adolescents: A summary and overview of different European guidelines. Eur J Pediatr. 2024 Mar;183(3):1047-1056. 
  2. Neurodivergence and substance use. Te Puna Whakaiti Pamamae Kai Whakapiri, New Zealand Drug Foundation, Sept 2024.https://drugfoundation.org.nz/articles/neurodivergence-and-substance-use
  3. Farmani R,. Exploring the link between toxic metal exposure and ADHD: a systematic review of lead and mercury. J Neurodev Disord. 2024;16(1):44. 
  4. Moore S, Paalanen L, Melymuk L, Katsonouri A, Kolossa-Gehring M, Tolonen H. The Association between ADHD and Environmental Chemicals-A Scoping Review. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Mar 1;19(5):2849.
  5. Oh J, Kim K, Kannan K, Parsons PJ, Mlodnicka A, Schmidt RJ, Schweitzer JB, Hertz-Picciotto I, Bennett DH. Early childhood exposure to environmental phenols and parabens, phthalates, organophosphate pesticides, and trace elements in association with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms in the CHARGE study. Environ Health. 2024 Mar 14;23(1):27. 
  6. Robinson DM, Edwards KL, Willoughby MT, Hamilton KR, Blair CB, Granger DA, Thomas EA. Increased risk of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in adolescents with high salivary levels of copper, manganese, and zinc. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2024 Sep;33(9):3091-3099
  7. Symeonides C, Aromataris E, Mulders Y, Dizon J, Stern C, Barker TH, Whitehorn A, Pollock D, Marin T, Dunlop S. An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses Evaluating Associations between Human Health and Exposure to Major Classes of Plastic-Associated Chemicals. Ann Glob Health. 2024 Aug 19;90(1):52.
  8. Compa M, Baumbach C, Kaczmarek-Majer K, Buczyłowska D, Gradys GO, Skotak K, Degórska A, Bratkowski J, Wierzba-Łukaszyk M, Mysak Y, Sitnik-Warchulska K, Lipowska M, Izydorczyk B, Grellier J, Asanowicz D, Markevych I, Szwed M. Air pollution and attention in Polish schoolchildren with and without ADHD. Sci Total Environ. 2023 Sep 20;892:164759.
  9. Meng Z, Ao B, Wang W, Niu T, Chen Y, Ma X, Huang Y. Relationships between screen time and childhood attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: a Mendelian randomization study. Front Psychiatry. 2024 Sep 23;15:1441191
  10. Namimi-Halevi C, Dor C, Dichtiar R, Bromberg M, Sinai T. Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder is associated with risky and unhealthy behaviours among adolescents. Public Health. 2024 Sep 25;237:51-56.
  11. Thorell LB, Burén J, Ström Wiman J, Sandberg D, Nutley SB. Longitudinal associations between digital media use and ADHD symptoms in children and adolescents: a systematic literature review. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2024 Aug;33(8):2503-2526.
  12. Ijomone OK et al. Dopaminergic Perturbation in the Aetiology of Neurodevelopmental Disorders. Mol Neurobiol. Published online August 7, 2024.
  13. Liu DY, Shen XM, Yuan FF, Guo OY, Zhong Y, Chen JG, Zhu LQ, Wu J. The Physiology of BDNF and Its Relationship with ADHD. Mol Neurobiol. 2015 Dec;52(3):1467-1476. 
  14. Donovan GH et al, Association between exposure to the natural environment, rurality, and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder in children in New Zealand: a linkage study. The Lancet Planetary Health, 2019; 3 (5): e226-e234
  15. Markevych I, Tesch F, Datzmann T, Romanos M, Schmitt J,  Heinrich J. Outdoor air pollution, greenspace, and incidence of ADHD: a semi-individual study. Sci Total Environ, 2018; 642:1362-1368
  16. Li HH, Yue XJ, Wang CX, Feng JY, Wang B, Jia FY. Serum Levels of Vitamin A and Vitamin D and Their Association With Symptoms in Children With Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. Front Psychiatry. 2020 Nov 23;11:599958
  17. Hemamy M, Pahlavani N, Amanollahi A, Islam SMS, McVicar J, Askari G, Malekahmadi M. The effect of vitamin D and magnesium supplementation on the mental health status of attention-deficit hyperactive children: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Pediatr. 2021 Apr 17;21(1):178
  18. Lange KW, Lange KM, Nakamura Y, Reissmann A. Nutrition in the Management of ADHD: A Review of Recent Research. Curr Nutr Rep. 2023 Sep;12(3):383-394.
  19. Schatz NK, Fabiano GA, Cunningham CE, dosReis S, Waschbusch DA, Jerome S, Lupas K, Morris KL. Systematic Review of Patients’ and Parents’ Preferences for ADHD Treatment Options and Processes of Care. Patient. 2015 Dec;8(6):483-97.
  20. https://herbblurb.com/2017/02/03/why-herbs-should-be-the-first-choice-of-treatment-for-acute-anxiety/
  21. Kean JD, Downey LA, Sarris J, Kaufman J, Zangara A, Stough C. Effects of Bacopa monnieri (CDRI 08®) in a population of males exhibiting inattention and hyperactivity aged 6 to 14 years: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Phytother Res. 2022;36(2):996-1012.
  22. Dave UP, Dingankar SR, Saxena VS, et al. An open-label study to elucidate the effects of standardized Bacopa monnieri extract in the management of symptoms of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder in children. Adv Mind Body Med. 2014;28(2):10-15.
  23. https://herbblurb.com/2021/01/29/lemon-balm-a-true-tonic-for-stress/
  24. Sun R, Yuan H, Wang J, Zhu K, Xiong Y, Zheng Y, Ni X, Huang M. Rehmanniae Radix Preparata ameliorates behavioral deficits and hippocampal neurodevelopmental abnormalities in ADHD rat model. Front Neurosci. 2024 May 30;18:1402056.
  25. Janda K, Wojtkowska K, Jakubczyk K, Antoniewicz J, Skonieczna-Żydecka K. Passiflora incarnata in Neuropsychiatric Disorders-A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2020;12(12):3894. 
  26. Trompetter I, Krick B, Weiss G. Herbal triplet in treatment of nervous agitation in children. Wien Med Wochenschr. 2013;163(3-4):52-57. 
  27. Amini F, Amini-Khoei H, Haratizadeh S, et al. Hydroalcoholic extract of Passiflora incarnata improves the autistic-like behavior and neuronal damage in a valproic acid-induced rat model of autism. J Tradit Complement Med. 2023;13(4):315-324.
  28. Golsorkhi H, Qorbani M, Sabbaghzadegan S, Dadmehr M. Herbal medicines in the treatment of children and adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): An updated systematic review of clinical trials. Avicenna J Phytomed. 2023;13(4):338-353.
  29. https://herbblurb.com/2017/02/03/why-herbs-should-be-the-first-choice-of-treatment-for-acute-anxiety/
  30. Rasmussen PL, St Johns Wort – Safety in Clinical Practice. Phytomed Webinar, available from Phytomed Medicinal Herbs Ltd, Auckland, New Zealand, February 2015

PROMISING NEW FINDINGS FOR ROSEMARY

The leaves and sprigs of Rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis), have been widely used in food preparation and preservation and also for many medicinal purposes, almost as far back as human history began. As a popular plant that is easy to use and often readily accessible, its reputation as a meat preserver and an alleged hair restorer, are fairly well known in herbal folklore.

As with other long-esteemed herbaceous plants, rosemary’s diverse medicinal capabilities and their relevance to the needs of a modern-day world are being increasingly validated by modern research.  Rosemary is now known to have some powerful pharmacological actions, including antioxidant, hepatoprotective, anti-cancer, antimicrobial and potential antidepressant activities(1).

Further possible medicinal uses for this well-known plant have now emerged, following results from recent research.

Preservative actions have long been assigned to rosemary, and scientific evidence supporting an antimicrobial application is very encouraging(2,3). An ethanolic rosemary extract was recently reported to have promising antibacterial activity against different pathogenic bacteria, with particularly good activity against Klebsiella pneumoniae(4). The essential oil of rosemary also exhibits powerful bactericidal (bacteria killing) and anti-biofilm activity against Staphylococcus aureusand Staphylococcus epidermidis(5), common causes of infections such as UTI’s and those from medical devices such as catheters.

Another study by veterinarian researchers recently, found that rosemary essential oil improved the motility of sperm collected from roosters, during its storage at 4 degrees C. These benefits were particularly seen when low concentrations of 8.7 and 87 ug/ml of rosemary essential oil were used. This suggests potential uses in animal fertilisation, and in human fertility clinics and procedures(6). With declining rates of sperm counts and motility, anything that gives sperm a greater chance of successfully fertilising an egg, can only be a good thing. As such it is conceivable that humans (or prehumans) may become exposed to this remarkable herb even before conception itself in the future!

Rosemary also has a reputation for helping prevent cancer, and application of rosemary or its phenolic acid constituents carnosol and ursolic acid were first shown to inhibit skin cancer formation in 1994(7).  Such actions have since been extended to other forms of cancer cells, including most recently the growth of human colon adenocarcinoma(8), and three other gastrointestinal cancer cell lines(9).

Benefits on heart health are also associated traditionally with regular ingestion of this herb, and recent studies on rodents have provided some support for this.  Pre-treatment with an aqueous rosemary extract protected mice against cardiotoxicity and hepatotoxicity(10). Supplementation of the diet of rats with 0.02% rosemary for three months improved diastolic function, and reduced the degree of hypertrophy after a heart attack (myocardial infarction). These effects were associated with improved energy metabolism and decreased oxidative stress(11). Rosmarinic acid has also shown a cardioprotective effect against myocardial infarction and arrhythmia in rats(12).

Collectively, these recent studies support further investigations into the potential use of rosemary as adjuvant therapy with other cardiac drugs in those at risk of a heart attack, or to be taken immediately following such life-threatening cardiac events.

Finally, rosemary is also used in traditional medicine to alleviate rheumatic and abdominal pain. In a rat model of painful diabetic neuropathy, rosemary extract improved hyperglycemia, hyperalgesia and motor deficit(13). Triterpene constituents of an ethanolic extract also reduce abdominal pain in mice(14). These findings suggest rosemary may have analgesic and neuroprotective effects in painful diabetic neuropathy as well as abdominal pain in humans. Rosmarinic acid is likely to contribute to these effects, as other recent studies found it effective in a rat model of neuropathic pain(15-17). Analgesic properties have also previously been reported for rosemary essential oil (18).

Rosmarinic acid is a highly valued phenolic compound found not only in Rosemary, but also in many other well-known plants in the Lamiaceae and Boraginaceae families, such as Sage, Lemon balm, and Perilla (Perilla frutescens). Potentially beneficial pharmacological properties of this natural compound include anticancer, anti-angiogenic, anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and antimicrobial activities(19,20). This has lead to increasing demands for it from the pharmaceutical industry. As a result, methods to chemically synthesise rosmarinic acid or produce it by biotechnological methods, are now being actively explored(19).

Beyond rosmarinic acid, however, the cumulative research into the diverse pharmacological actions of the reliable rosemary, show that other phenolic acids, triterpenoids, essential oil and other constituents, also seem to make powerful contributions to its many potential medicinal uses.

 

References:

  1. Andrade JM et al, Future Sci OA. 2018 Feb 1;4(4):FSO283.
  2. Ahn J et al, Food Microbiol. 2007 Feb;24(1):7-14
  3. Nieto G et al, Medicines (Basel).2018 Sep 4;5(3).
  4. Javed H 1stal, Pam J Pharm Sci 2018; 31(3):933-939.
  5. Jardak M et al, Lipids Health Dis. 2017 Oct 2;16(1):190.
  6. TouaziL et al, Vel World 2018; 11(5):590-597.
  7. Huang lT et al, Cancer Res.1994 Feb 1;54(3):701-8.
  8. Jaksevicius A, et al, Nutrients. 2017 Sep 21;9(10).
  9. Karimi N, Gastroenterol Hepatol Bed Bench. 2017 Spring;10(2):102-107.
  10. Hamed H et al, Appl Physiol Nutr Metab.2018 Apr 9. doi: 10.1139/apnm-2017-0786. [Epub ahead of print]
  11. Murino Rafacho BP, PLoS One. 2017 May 11;12(5):e0177521
  12. Javidanpour S et al, 2017 Dec;51(11-12):911-923.
  13. Rasoulian B et al, J Physiol Sci 2018; May 12 (epub ahead of print).
  14. Martinez AL et al, J Ethnopharmacol 2012; 142(1):28-34.
  15. Rahbardar GM et al, Biomed Pharmacother. 2017 Feb;86:441-449
  16. Rahbardar MGet al 2018 Feb 1;40:59-67
  17. Di Cesare Mannelli L et al,Sci Rep. 2016 Oct 7;6:34832.
  18. Raskovic A, et al, Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2015 Jan;19(1):165-72.
  19. Swamy MK et al, Appl Micriobil Biotechnol 2018.
  20. Shekarchi M et al, Pharmacognosy Mag 2012; 8(29):37-41.

WITHANIA: A USEFUL ADJUNCT WITH ANTIPSYCHOTIC MEDICATIONS

Antipsychotic drugs are strong medicines, and while they can successfully alleviate symptoms of psychosis and prevent relapse of schizophrenia and related conditions, like all drugs they are not without side effects.

There are two types of antipsychotics, older generation ones such as chlorpromazine or haloperidol developed in the 1960s, and so called ‘atypical’ antipsychotics such as olanzapine, clozapine and quetiapine developed in the 1990s, with a different side effect profile. While atypical newer generation antipsychotics are less likely than older generation ones to produce the extrapyramidal or Parkinson’s disease-like side effects, they can cause weight gain and precipitate or worsen metabolic syndrome or diabetes, and both types increase the risk of sudden cardiac death. Over-use and mis-use of antipsychotics is also of growing concern in the elderly(1).

Despite these risks, in a world in which the incidence and predominance of mental health conditions is rising, prescribing rates for antipsychotic drugs are increasing. Nearly seven million Americans take antipsychotic medications, and a recent study revealed a 49% rise in the use of anti-psychotic drugs by New Zealanders between 2008 and 2015. New Zealanders are now 60% more likely to be prescribed such drugs than Australians, with one in 36 New Zealand adults, or 2.81% of the population, being prescribed antipsychotic medication in 2015(2).

This recent New Zealand study also suggests that in a significant and probably increasing number of cases, these strong prescription-only drugs are being used to help with stress and associated sleep problems, rather than for their primary indication for conditions such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorders. Such ‘off label’ uses for prescription-only antipsychotics such as olanzapine, is something that has landed pharmaceutical companies in court in the U.S., in a number of prominent cases.

Herbal medicine offers an array of potential treatments for insomnia and stress-related conditions(3). One of the most suitable of these is Withania somnifera (Withania), known as Ashwagandha in India. The roots of Withania have a subtle but powerful nervous system and adrenal tonic action which insulates the nervous system from stress, enabling it to be better prepared to respond appropriately to the ‘fight or flight’ response. Many studies now support its applications for stress-associated anxiety conditions, including several human clinical trials(3).

Another possible application for Withania became apparent recently, through an American clinical trial where it was used as an adjunctive treatment alongside antipsychotic drug treatment in patients with schizophrenia(4). A total of 66 patients who had recently experienced an exacerbation of their schizophrenia symptoms, were given Withania or placebo alongside their usual antipsychotic drug medications, for a 12 week period. Outcomes were change from baseline to end of treatment on the “Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale” (PANSS), which measures total, positive, negative, and general symptoms of schizophrenia, and indices of stress and inflammation.

Patients given Withania were significantly more likely to achieve at least 20% improvements in PANSS negative, general, and total symptom scores, but not positive symptom scores, compared to those assigned to placebo. They also showed a significant improvement in stress scores compared to placebo. Additionally, only two of the Withania-treated subjects required an increase in their antipsychotic drug dosage, whereas nine of the placebo-assigned subjects either had their antipsychotic drug dosage increased or had a second antipsychotic drug added. These improvements were first noted at 4 weeks, and continued through the 12-week study period.

This is not the first time that Withania has been shown to be useful when taken alongside antipsychotic drugs. A one month clinical trial involving 30 schizophrenia patients with metabolic syndrome who had taken second generation antipsychotics for more than 6 months, found that adding Withania to their normal antipsychotic medication reduced serum triglycerides and fasting blood glucose, thus improving these metabolic syndrome symptoms(5).

Apart from Withania, clinical trials have shown appropriate doses of other high quality herbal medicines to benefit patients receiving antipsychotic drugs. Ginkgo was found to both increase the response rate to haloperidol when taken alongside it for 12 weeks(6), and to reduce the incidence of extrapyramidal side effects(7, 8). Similar effects have also been reported using Ginkgo alongside olanzapine(9).

Another U.S. study has shown American Ginseng (Panax quinquefolium) to have positive effects on memory function in individuals with schizophrenia, and to reduce the occurrence of extrapyramidal symptoms in patients on antipsychotic medications(10).

While underlying reasons for the high and increasing level of antipsychotic drug use in New Zealand and other countries should be further examined and addressed, clinical trials suggest that adjunctive herbal medicines such as Withania, Ginkgo and American ginseng, can play a role to help reduce some of the adverse events, and improve their response rates. Larger and longer term trials, are warranted.

References:
1. Bjerre LE; Canadian Fam Physician 2018; 64(1):17-27
2. Wilkinson S, Mulder RT. NZ Med J 2018 Aug 17; 131(1480):61-67.
3. Rasmussen PL, Feb 2017; Why Herbs should be the first choice of treatment for acute    anxiety. http://www.herbblurb.com
4. Chengappa KNR et al, J Clin Psychiatry 2018 Jul 10;79(5).
5. Agnihotri AP et al, Indian J Pharmacol 2013; Jul-Aug;45(4):417-8
6. Zhang XY et al, Psychopharmacology 2006; 188(1):12-17.
7. Zhang XY et al, J Clin Psychiatry 2001; 62(11):878-883.
8. Chen X et al, Psychiatry Res 2015; 228(1):121-127.
9. Atmaca M et al, Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2005; 59(6):652- 656.
10. Chen EY et al, Phytother Res. 2012 Aug;26(8):1166-72

Medicinal Uses of Nasturtium

With spring upon us, the New Zealand countryside and our gardens are rich with budding and flowering plants, many of them normally regarded as weeds, but in fact highly medicinal.

One of these is Nasturtium (Tropaelum majus; Indian cress), a plant with water lily like circular leaves and bright yellow, orange and red flowers which is native to South America but established in many warmer areas of New Zealand and Australia. While it can certainly be very weedy in some situations, it also makes a useful plant on the edges of the vegetable garden to attract bees and other beneficial insects. It can also act as a decoy by attracting cabbage white butterflies and drawing these pests away from brassicas.

What many people don’t realise, however, is that all parts of Nasturtium are edible, with its leaves and flowers making a decorative, peppery addition to salads, and the fruits when pickled with vinegar serving as a tasty alternative to capers. It also has outstanding antioxidant activity due to its rich content of phenolic compounds, including anthocyanin and vitamin C. Like many ‘weeds’ readily available in the New Zealand environment, Nasturtium is also a highly medicinal plant.

Traditionally it was used to help ward off and treat various infections, particularly those affecting the lungs and the urinary tract. The pungent compounds known as isothiocyanates found in all parts of nasturtium and roots of horseradish (Armoracia rusticana), have powerful and fairly broad spectrum antibacterial activities particularly against Haemophilus influenza and Moraxella catarrhalis, a common cause of middle ear infection (otitis media) and sinusitus in children(1). These isothiocyanates have also recently been reported to have good activity against both developing and mature biofilms of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, a bacterial pathogen associated with many serious human illnesses(2). Importantly also, they have also been shown to be well absorbed into the bloodstream following oral ingestion of nasturtium in humans(3).

Nasturtium was used in folk medicine as a remedy against scurvy, and can be used as a natural, warming remedy to help the body overcome and prevent the common cold and influenza. It was also used traditionally to treat muscular pain, and it’s antimicrobial properties extend to its use as a topical treatment for bacterial infections and minor scrapes and cuts.

Possible applications in the prevention or treatment of various cancers are also likely, due to conversion of a key constituent glucotropaeolin to benzyl isothiocyanate, within the body. This compound, formed also from isothiocyanates found in brassica (cruciferous) vegetables, exhibits anticancer activity against cultured lung, breast, liver, prostate, brain, melanoma, oral & ovarian cancer cells in vitro, and prevents chemically induced carcinogenesis in rodents(4-10).

Potential benefits in fluid retention, hypertension and other cardiovascular conditions, have been suggested by Brazilian research showing diuretic, hypotensive and lipid-lowering activities for a hydroethanolic extract in rats(11-13). Angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibition was implicated as a possible mechanism for these effects, in a similar manner to how ACE inhibitor drugs work to help manage hypertension and other cardiovascular conditions(14). Unlike many other conventional diuretic drugs, however, no unwanted effects on urinary calcium or potassium excretion seem to occur, suggesting valuable potassium and calcium-sparing properties. These findings indicate possible applications also to help prevent osteoporosis, which is supported by another Brazilian study in menopausal rats(13).

Nasturtium may also be useful to help prevent or manage obesity, according to findings from a Korean study published in the June 2017 issue of the journal Food and Nutrition Research(15). The study investigated the effects of a nasturtium ethanolic extract on a mouse cell line with adipocyte-like characteristics, used in research on adipose (fat) tissue. Treatment of cells with nasturtium extract produced a concentration-dependent reduction in lipid accumulation, and inhibited the expression of various proteins associated with differentiation of fat cells. This suggests potential usefulness also, in the prevention and treatment of obesity.

With these compelling research findings, incorporation of nasturtium into the diet or herbal treatments of a range of human conditions common in the 21st century, should overtake our view of it simply as a bothersome weed.

References:

  1. Conrad A et al, Drug Res (Stuttg). 2013 Feb;63(2):65-8.
  2. Kaiser SJ et al, 2017 Jun;119:57-63.
  3. PPlatz S et al, Mol Nutr Food Res. 2016 Mar;60(3):652-60..See comment in PubMed Commons below
  4. Wattenberg LW. J Natl Cancer 1977 Feb;58(2):395-8.
  5. Hecht SS et al. J Nutr. 1999 Mar;129(3):768S-774S.
  6. Cho HJ et al, Int J Mol Sci 2016 Feb 22; 17(2):264
  7. Shang HS et al, Environ Toxicol 2016 Dec; 31(12):1751-1760.
  8. Yeh YT et al. Food Chem Toxicol. 2016 Nov;97:336-345.
  9. Zhu M et al J Cancer. 2017 Jan 15;8(2):240-248.
  10. Lai KC et al, Int J Oncol. 2017 Sep;51(3):832-840.
  11. Gasparotto Junior A et al. J Ethnopharmacol. 2009 Apr 21;122(3):517-22.
  12. Gasparotto Junior A et al. J Ethnopharmacol. 2011 Mar 24;134(2):210-5.
  13. Barboza LN et al, Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2014; 2014:958291.
  14. Gasparotto Junior A et al J Ethnopharmacol. 2011 Mar 24;134(2):363-72. (2011a)
  15. Kim GC et al,.Food Nutr Res. 2017 Jun 14;61(1):1339555.

 

Manuka and Myrtle Rust

Last week I attended a two day workshop organised by scientists at Plant and Food Research Ltd and Massey University in Palmerston North, to discuss a range of recent scientific and biosecurity developments, concerning Manuka (Leptospermum scoparium), an important plant in New Zealand’s natural environment and economy. As with the two day Hui on ‘Manuka and More’ in Ruatoria and Te Araroa in November last year, this was an excellent event in which more than 30 scientists working actively on Manuka research presented on a diverse range of subjects and discussed where there could be gaps in our knowledge or research needs for this plant. While Manuka Honey and essential oil are currently the main two medicinal products produced from Manuka, numerous other therapeutic applications and potential contributions to preserving our environment, are found within this plant.

Jacqui Horswell and colleagues from the Institute of Environmental Science and Research, have shown that Manuka and other myrtaceaeous plants seem to be capable of killing the faecal bacterial pathogen Enterobacter coli (E. coli), by enhancing the die-off of this and other pathogenic organisms that pass through their root systems. A field trial involving riparian planting of Manuka is just getting going, to see whether laboratory results extend to helping to reduce animal effluent flows into a polluted lake. A lake which was once pristine and a treasured swimming area, but in recent years has changed into a green and dirty waterway due largely to dairy industry runoff, has been selected for this trial.

Hayley Ridgway from Lincoln University presented some interesting findings concerning novel and potentially useful mycorrhizae (fungi) and endophytic bacteria associated with the roots of Manuka, some of which I wrote about in my previous blog. Inoculation of Manuka plants with different mycorrhizae causes significant alterations in their growth rates and essential oil composition, highlighting the complex inter-relationships between microbes associated with Manuka, and its production of phytochemicals including some with bioactive properties.

Other presentations were made on experiences to date involving plantations of Manuka which have been established at a number of North Island sites in recent years. Challenges include site access, weeds, pests, and the relative attractiveness of different genetic lines to bees. A comment made by one of the presenters that while humans have had multiple generations of experience with cultivation and enhancing performance characteristics of crops such as wheat and rice, our experience with Manuka plantations spans less than 10-15 years to date.

The hottest topic at the workshop, however, was the recent finding of isolated outbreaks of Myrtle Rust (Austropuccinia psidii) in New Zealand nursery and garden grown specimens of Manuka and the native tree, Ramarama (Lophomyrtus bullata). This pathogenic fungi originated from Brazil where it causes guava rust, but spread internationally into North America in the 1880’s, and was first reported in Australia in 2010.  Australia is home to around half of the world’s Myrtaceae (Myrtle family) plant species, including Eucalyptus (850 species), Melaleuca (176 species) and Callistemon species.

Outbreak of Myrtle rust has had a devastating effect on much of the east coast as well as other areas of Australia, where it has resulted in ecosystem collapse for certain plant species. To date it has only been found in isolated locations in Northland, Waikato, Bay of Plenty and Taranaki, although it is widespread on Raoul Island in the Kermadec group, about 1,100km to the north-east of New Zealand.

Myrtle rust spores can easily spread across large distances by wind, or via insects, birds, people, or machinery, and it is thought the fungus arrived in New Zealand carried by strong winds and significant weather events from Australia.

The Myrtle Rust Strategic Science Advisory Group is working hard to assess and try to ameliorate the widespread environmental, economic, social and cultural impacts this plant pathogen could have on New Zealand. Apart from Manuka and Ramarama, other indigenous Myrtaceae species such as Pohutakawa (Metrosideros spp) and Swamp Maire (Syzygium maire), are under risk. Priorities including acceleration of scientific research into the biology of the pandemic strain detected here, pathways of spread, surveillance, management, exploring plant susceptibility and resistance, and coordinating and communicating a management plan that has widespread engagement by communities, scientists, industry and Maori stakeholders and landowners, councils and government.

The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) and the Department of Conservation (DOC), with the help of local iwi, the nursery industry, and local authorities are running an operation to determine the scale of the situation and to try and contain and control myrtle rust in the areas it has been found. However, emergence of the infection and appearance of the distinctive yellow or brown leaf discolouration may not become fully apparent until the spring, and a better assessment of the number of infection sites and their extent, may not be possible until then.

The arrival of Myrtle Rust in New Zealand means that the task of collecting and storing seed of New Zealand indigenous Myrtaceae including Manuka, has now become urgent. The NZ Indigenous Flora Seed Bank (NZIFSB), a collaborative project between Massey University, AgResearch, Landcare and the Department of Conservation, with support from the NZ Plant Conservation Network and the Millennium Seedbank at Kew in the UK, was established in 2013. NZFISB has been doing some really valuable work to collect and store seeds aimed at preserving a wide range of biodiversity within New Zealand native plant species. More than 130 volunteer seed collectors have been trained to date, and plans are underway to extend this and the level of community participation, to try to better protect our native plants for generations to come.

Refs:

http://www.nzpcn.org.nz/page.aspx?conservation_seedbank

http://www.mpi.govt.nz/protection-and-response/responding/alerts/myrtle-rust/

Antimicrobial Endophytes in Echinacea, Olive and Manuka

While plants are being extensively explored for new therapeutic properties and pharmacological activities, the communities of live fungi and bacteria known as endophytes that live between living plant cells, are also now being regarded as having many useful potential medicinal applications. Ironically, in recent years it is these microorganisms associated with plants rather than plants themselves, which seem to be receive much research interest.

Endophytes are microorganisms that live within a plant for at least part of their life cycles, without causing apparent disease or infections in the plant. Different endophytes seem to have affinities for particular plants, with which they have distinctive and cherished but complex interactions while each of them grows. They are for instance known to sometimes enhance host growth and nutrient gain, improve the plant’s ability to tolerate various types of stressors, and enhance the its resistance to insects and pests. The rrelationships that these bacteria and fungal communities have with their host plant varies from symbiotic to parasitic, to bordering on pathogenic.
Some very unusual and valuable bioactive substances are sometimes produced by these endophytes, such as alkaloids, phenolic acids, quinones, steroids, saponins, tannins, and terpenoids, and these are increasingly being recognized as sources of novel compounds which may help to maintain or solve not only the plant’s health challenges, but can also have applications in human and animal health problems.
Over the past few decades, some highly medicinal compounds produced by endophytic microbes lead to novel drug development. These include Taxol (paclitaxol), a complex diterpene alkaloid produced by the endophyte Metarhizium anisopliae found in the bark of the Pacific Yew (Taxus brevifolia) tree, and one of the most promising anticancer agents ever developed. Also streptomycin, an antibiotic produced from the bacterial endophyte Streptomyces.

Other endophytes possess antibacterial activities which may be useful in treating various infections, and in a world where antibiotic resistance is becoming a major public health threat, these are obviously of great interest. Exploring and bioprospecting these for potential antimicrobial compounds may well yield valuable new natural products or drugs to help in the fight against resistant organisms(1,2,3,4).

It now seems that bacterial communities colonizing Echinacea purpurea contribute to its well-known immune enhancing activity(5). American researchers have reported that Echinacea’s stimulating activity on monocytes (a type of white blood cell involved in engulfing and destroying harmful microbes), could be solely if not partially accounted for by the activities and prevalence of Proteobacteria, a family of bacteria found in the bacterial community associated with this medicinal plant.
A screen of 151 different endophytic bacteria isolated from three different compartments of Echinacea purpurea, revealed that several bacteria isolated from the roots are strong inhibitors of Burkholderia cepacia complex bacteria, a serious threat particularly in immune-compromised cystic fibrosis patients(6). One of these bacterial strains also showed antimicrobial effects against Acinetobacter baumannii, a pathogenic bacteria mainly associated with hospital-acquired infections, and Klebsiella pneumoniae, also increasingly incriminated in hospital infections(7). Interestingly, the type of bacteria and their antimicrobial effects varied considerably, according to which part of the plant (root, stem, leaves etc) they were associated with. This has resemblances to different plant parts of Echinacea having different phytochemical and thus pharmacological activities, such as Echinacea roots being richest in alkylamides and thus anti-inflammatory activities.

Endophytic fungi including Penicillium commune and Penicillium canescens (related to the Penicillium notatum mould from which the first antibiotic penicillin originated), have also been isolated from the leaves of olive (Olea europaea) trees, and several of these have also shown antibacterial as well as antifungal activities in recent work(8).

Finally, a rich endophyte community has recently been identified by Lincoln University researchers for the New Zealand native plant Manuka (Leptospermum scoparium). A total of 192 culturable bacteria were recovered from leaves, stems and roots, including some showing activity against the bacterial pathogen, Pseudomonas syringae pv. actinidiae(9), otherwise known by Kiwifruit growers as Psa. With Psa being a serious risk to the health of the Kiwifruit vine, it could be that these endophytic bacteria found within Manuka will make a useful contribution to ensuring the future health of the Kiwifruit industry.
While very few of all of the world’s plants have had their complete complement of endophytes studied, these are just three well established medicinal plants from which some highly active cohabitating bacteria and fungi have been sourced. Undoubtedly this area of research will receive much more attention due to growing concerns about antibiotic resistance, as there would seem to be a huge opportunity to find new and interesting endophytes among the wealth of different plants growing not only in soil, but also in waterways and oceans.
Refs:
1. Alvin A et al, Microbiol Res 2014; 169(7-8)L483-495.
2. Martinez-Klimova E et al, Biochem Pharmacol 2016; Oct 27.
3. Kealey C et al, Biotechnol Lett 2017; Mar 8 (epub ahead of print)
4. Tanwar A et al, Microbiol Path 2016;101:76-82
5. Haron MH et al, Planta Med 2016; 82(14):1258-1265.
6. Chiellini C et al, Microbiol Res 2017; 196:34-43.
7. Presta L et al, Res Microbiol 2017; 168(3):293-305.
8. Malhadas C et al, World J Microbiol Biotechnol 2017; 33(3):46.
9. Wicaksono WA et al, PLoS One 2016; 11(9):e0163717.